Complete Story
 

GRANT, A. J.

Fall 2000, pages 49-82

Vico and Bultmann on Myth: The Problem with Demythologizing

Abstract: Giambattista Vico (1668-1744), an early Enlightenment critic of Cartesianism, on one hand, demystifies the origin and nature of myths, while Buhmann (1884-1976), a late modernist theologian, on the other, engages in a full-blown program of demythologizing. Vico subjects myth to analysis and scrutiny, but finds lasting value in the big stories whereas Buhmann, informed by a developmental view of history and a positivistic epistemology, finds little of value in the Christian Myth, apart from an existential encounter with God. Vico sees a clear connection among the imagination, metaphor, myth and critical method, but Bultmann, uses formgeschichte (form criticism) to expurgate the NT of myth.
Read the Rhetoric Society Quarterly Get information about our conferences Get information about our institutes Learn about becoming a member Access members-only content